Efforts to increase how much philanthropic funding goes to minority-led environmental organizations are gaining momentum, with one group’s push for transparency from the nation’s top climate donors drawing big-name support.
For months, Donors of Color Network, a philanthropic group dedicated to funding racial-equity efforts, has asked the top 40 climate funders to disclose what percentage of their funding during the past two years have gone to organizations led by Black, Indigenous, Latino, or other racial minorities, and to pledge at least 30 percent of their climate donations to such groups.
On Thursday, two of them — the California-based William & Flora Hewlett Foundation and the Boston-based Barr Foundation — released data that shows 10 percent of their climate funding went to minority-led environmental justice groups. That number was 31 percent at the New York-based JPB Foundation, another top donor.
With those announcements, five of the top 40 donors have released their data from the last two years, along with another nine smaller funders. Donors of Color says four of the top 40 donors — and a dozen other foundations — have signed its pledge, agreeing to meet the 30 percent minimum the group has set and release their funding data.
Advocates for environmental justice — which promotes fair treatment of racial minorities and low-income residents when dealing with environmental issues — argue more funding for their groups is needed to win the climate-change debate.
A study released last year from the New School showed that in 2016 and 2017, environmental-justice groups received just 1.3 percent of the funding earmarked for climate organizations in the Gulf and Midwest regions.
“Engaging those communities in decision-making [and] in the solutions for climate is essential,” said Miya Yoshitani, the executive director of the Oakland-based Asian Pacific Environmental Network and a member of the White House Environmental Justice Advisory Council. It’s important, she said, for communities “to see themselves as part of the solution to this incredible and enormous problem.”
The Hewlett Foundation is one of three top donors that only agreed to the transparency portion of the pledge. Larry Kramer, the president of Hewlett, says the organization declined to pledge 30 percent of its climate funding toward minority-led groups as a matter of “both legal and policy judgment.”
“We don’t think there are magic numbers,” Kramer said. “We prefer to do our grant making, be transparent about it, and always be working to improve.”
Kramer says the foundation is doing other things to improve diversity among its climate grantee pool, including employing efforts to make its own staff — and the staff of the organizations it supports — more diverse.
Five of the top 40 donors have declined the pledge, with some citing that their climate funding is mostly done outside of the United States, according to the Donors of Color Network.
Ashindi Maxton, the executive director of the organization, says the group is in conversation with more than two dozen of the other top donors about the pledge, though some say they don’t sign pledges.
“No one has said that they don’t sort of agree with the ultimate end goals of what we’re doing,” she said. “A lot of people just have a lot of internal machinery to move to do this.”
Editor’s note: This article is part of a partnership the Chronicle has forged with the Associated Press and the Conversation to expand coverage of philanthropy and nonprofits. The three organizations receive support for this work from the Lilly Endowment. The AP is solely responsible for the content in this article.
(The Hewlett Foundation is a financial supporter of the Chronicle of Philanthropy.)
